HEAD TO HEAD · FOR AUSTRALIAN BUSINESSES

Both are Australian-built AI scribes that listen to consultations and draft clinical notes. Choose Lyrebird if you are a GP on Best Practice and want deep integration that also drafts care plans, health assessments and forms inside your clinical software. Choose Heidi if you work across specialties or settings, want a generous free tier, or need tools beyond scribing such as dictation, evidence answers and task agents. Both say they do not keep consultation audio. Whichever you choose, AHPRA expects informed patient consent and that you review every note before it goes in the record.

001 / SIDE BY SIDE

BEST AT

Heidi Health:Flexible scribing across specialties, with dictation, evidence answers and task agents in one tool.

Lyrebird Health:General practice on Best Practice, including care plans, health assessments and forms.

PLAN STRUCTURE

Heidi Health:Free plan with unlimited transcription, paid Clinician and Practice plans, and Enterprise.

Lyrebird Health:Limited free plan, a free plan for Best Practice users, Pro, and Enterprise.

EMR INTEGRATION

Heidi Health:EHR integrations on paid plans, including Best Practice; otherwise copy notes across.

Lyrebird Health:Deep Best Practice integration, plus Genie, Gentu and browser workflows for other systems.

DATA STORAGE

Heidi Health:Australian customer data hosted in Australia, with some offshore processing disclosed; check the processing agreement.

Lyrebird Health:Says data is processed and stored in Australia.

AUDIO AND TRAINING

Heidi Health:Audio is not stored after notes are generated; review terms on secondary use.

Lyrebird Health:No audio retained after the consult and no model training on patient data.

CERTIFICATIONS

Heidi Health:ISO 27001 and SOC 2.

Lyrebird Health:Ask for current security certifications and audit reports during procurement.

TEAM AND ADMIN CONTROLS

Heidi Health:Team template sharing and management on paid plans; SSO and custom hosting on Enterprise.

Lyrebird Health:Team templates and central billing; organisation sharing and SSO on Enterprise.

REACH

Heidi Health:Used internationally across many specialties and some Australian hospitals.

Lyrebird Health:Focused on Australian general practice and specialists, with hospital trials such as Gold Coast Health.

LEARNING CURVE

Heidi Health:Quick to start; templates take time to tune to your style.

Lyrebird Health:Quick for Best Practice users because it works inside the clinical software.

002 / WHICH ONE FOR YOU

Pick Heidi Health if…

  • ✓You work in a specialty, allied health or a setting outside general practice
  • ✓You want a capable free tier before paying
  • ✓You use clinical software other than Best Practice
  • ✓You want dictation, evidence lookups and task help in the same tool

Pick Lyrebird Health if…

  • ✓You are a GP using Best Practice and want notes written straight into the record
  • ✓You want help drafting care plans, health assessments and WorkCover or NDIS forms
  • ✓Onshore processing and storage of all data is a firm requirement
  • ✓Your practice uses Genie or Gentu

OUR VERDICT

For GPs on Best Practice, Lyrebird's in-software integration and help with care plans and forms make it the more efficient choice, and its fully onshore data claim is simple to explain to patients. For specialists, allied health, hospitals or clinicians on other systems, Heidi's flexibility, free tier and wider feature set make it the stronger option. Both are credible Australian products. Trial each for a fortnight, check note accuracy closely, and confirm data terms in writing before signing.

003 / FOR AUSTRALIAN BUSINESSES

Data that can't leave Australia? →

AHPRA's guidance on using AI in healthcare says practitioners remain responsible for records and must obtain informed patient consent. The RACGP advises reviewing every note, preferring Australian data storage and checking secondary data use. Some states treat recording a private conversation without consent as a criminal offence. Health information is sensitive information under the Privacy Act 1988, and state health records laws may also apply. Scribes that only summarise generally fall outside TGA device regulation, but features that suggest diagnoses or treatment may not. Talk to your medical defence organisation before rollout.

004 / QUESTIONS

Anything else is quicker to answer on a call. Thirty minutes, free, with the people who would build it.

Yes. AHPRA and the RACGP expect informed consent before an AI scribe listens to a consultation, and some states make recording without consent an offence. Explain what the tool does, record consent in the notes, and offer a way to opt out.

We use both every week. Tell us the job and we'll tell you which we'd pick, and how we'd set it up safely.

Book a free call→